Texas lawmakers pass so-called ‘frat house’ bill, stripping cities of power to dictate how many unrelated people can live in one place — but here’s why not everyone is celebrating

Reasoning for the bill

The idea for the bill started when Texas A&M students raised awareness about the occupancy limits that make housing less affordable for students.

Around 72,000 students attend Texas A&M's College Station campus, but only 11,000 live on campus. That means thousands of students are left to find off-campus housing, and not all properties are created equal.

A College Station Existing Conditions report showed that 58% of renters are considered “cost burdened” and that 35% of these renters are “severely cost burdened.”

That means more than half of the renters in College Town are spending at least 30% of their income on housing, while those who are severely cost burdened are spending more than 50%.

A&M student representatives argued at the November 7, 2024 Texas Local Government Senate Committee meeting that current ordinance restrictions are driving housing prices up, according to My Aggie Nation. Many students echoed their frustrations, and that housing continues to be a major challenge.

Senator Paul Bettencourt was present at the meeting and declared the need for action, saying, “We’re gonna have to do something about this,” according to My Aggie Nation.

He believes that ordinance restrictions force renters into more expensive options and that removing it could help ease the burden for college students.

As per the bill analysis, Senator Bettencourt also argues that the “ordinances restrict individual property owners and tenants from maximizing the use of a dwelling unit's potential” and believes that some municipalities that have enforced them engaged in behavior that could be considered “harassment under revised penal code statutes.”

Supporters of the bill also believe that its passing would help make housing more available and affordable.

Invest in real estate without the headache of being a landlord

Imagine owning a portfolio of thousands of well-managed single family rentals or a collection of cutting-edge industrial warehouses. You can now gain access to a $1B portfolio of income-producing real estate assets designed to deliver long-term growth from the comforts of your couch.

The best part? You don’t have to be a millionaire and can start investing in minutes.

Learn More

Why some are opposed

Not everyone is happy about the bill passing the Senate and currently moving through the House.

According to Fox 4 News, Texas Senator Robert Nichols argued the passing of the bill could have negative consequences. Specifically, single-family zoning could disappear as developers aim to drive profits.

Nichols claims when he was mayor of Jacksonville, Texas, he received many complaints and that cities probably have a valid reason to enforce these occupancy limits.

At the March 17 hearing of the Texas Senate Committee on Local Government, he said the city had slum lords who would petition “off all these rooms and rent out the rooms” and not to believe that renters are “college kids who are trying to be good neighbors.”

Some, like a representative from the College Station Association on Neighborhoods, said during the hearing that the bill could mean that investors would snatch up homes, making it harder for families.

During a March 27 meeting with the House Land and Resource Management Committee, College Station mayor John Nichols also testified against the bill.

He argued that the city enforces the ordinance because it helps to balance the needs of housing for students and families

Councilman Bob Yancy concluded with his argument that “stuffing more people into existing properties is not the answer, more housing is.”

But for now, the fate of housing regulations is unknown until the Texas House casts its vote.