'Finally said no': Airline passenger's seat-swap rejection sparks flurry of support. Here's what an etiquette expert has to say — and how to get the seat you want without breaking the bank

The debate

The story drew significant attention. Commenters applauded the decision and shared similar experiences, suggesting that the couple could have paid for seat selection and that there should be mutual benefit when switching seats. One commenter also wrote, “If you're brave enough to ask, you have to be brave enough to handle a NO."

The post highlights how passengers broadly view personal boundaries on flights. While some view these requests as innocent and situational, others argue they're presumptuous — especially when made without offering a comparable seat or when the seats weren't selected in advance. It's often about asserting personal comfort and agency in a high-stress, confined environment.

"The person making the request has no right to expect [this] or make a scene when they don’t get their way,” etiquette expert Rosalinda Randall told Fox News.

Randall pointed out the circumstances when it might be reasonable or only mildly inconvenient to switch: during a short flight, when there's a comparable seat elsewhere or if you'd prefer to sit apart from your current neighbor.

Similarly, a commenter said they would only give up their seat for a person bumped from another flight and consequently split up from their child or someone with special needs.

Scammers are smarter than ever—are you protected?

The average American gets 2 scam calls and 3 scam texts every week. Think you can spot them? AI is making scams harder to detect, and in 2023 alone, Americans lost $12.5B to cybercrime. Don’t be next—learn how to protect yourself now!

Learn more

Secure ideal seats and avoid the swap dilemma

To avoid the discomfort of being asked to switch seats or feeling pressured to ask someone to switch for you, it's important to plan ahead. Remember, while consumer rights vary by airline, typically, seat assignments aren't guaranteed unless reserved.

Here are some tips to get your preferred seating arrangement:

• Book early. The earlier you book your flight, the better your chances of selecting desirable seats, especially when traveling with others.
• Use seat selection tools. Most airlines offer online seat maps from which to choose seats during booking or check-in.
• Join loyalty programs. Frequent flyer status can offer you early seat selection access, preferred seating options or complimentary upgrades.
• Pay for preferred seats. If sitting together is important, consider the upgrade fee for guaranteed adjacent seats.

How to navigate the conversation smoothly

Despite best efforts, the switching question can still come up. But seat-swapping doesn't have to be tense. Come from a place of humility and understanding. If you’re asking, do so politely and, obviously, never with the assumption that someone is obligated to accommodate you.

Likewise, if you're asked and feel uncomfortable responding, remember, you're entitled to the seat you booked. Standing your ground and advocating for yourself will bring you peace of mind.

You can be kind and respectful yet firm and assertive, without guilt. Short, direct responses are usually best, and you don't owe anyone an explanation. Here are a few polite yet assured things to say:

• “No, thank you — I prefer to keep this seat,” is concise and clear.
• “I specifically booked this seat,” indicates your choice wasn’t random.
• “Sorry, but I’m not comfortable switching,” courteously sets a boundary.