New York’s finance department in charge of parking fines
New York City’s Department of Finance oversees the Parking Violation Bureau, and judges paid by the city’s finance department make decisions on parking violation appeals.
Retired lawyer Larry Berezin, who runs a blog to inform people about New York City parking tickets, believes this is a conflict.
“The mission of the Department of Finance is to raise money,” he says.
The department collected $46 million in parking ticket revenue in 2024. New York City issued 16 million tickets in 2024 for illegal parking and traffic violations.
But quite a few people appealed their case — 457,000 had their fines dismissed, representing 30% of the parking violation appeals heard in court.
Unfortunately, when Colon appealed, the judge still found him guilty — despite proof Colon sold the truck, surrendered his license plate and canceled truck insurance. Colon said the judge deemed that “insufficient evidence.”
He and his wife were concerned Colon’s wages would be garnished to pay for the violations, so his wife paid $600 toward the fines.
The good news is that when CBS News got involved, the Department of Finance connected Colon with its parking summons case legal advocate. Tse is resolving the case for Colon.
"Once (the fines are) dismissed, I should receive a refund," Colon said.
In addition, the DMV has raised concerns with New York City’s Department of Finance about parking ticket violations being based on outdated information. For its part, the finance department said “timing issues” were involved in Colon’s case, but added no further details.
This 2 minute move could knock $500/year off your car insurance in 2025
OfficialCarInsurance.com lets you compare quotes from trusted brands, such as Progressive, Allstate and GEICO to make sure you're getting the best deal.
You can switch to a more affordable auto insurance option in 2 minutes by providing some information about yourself and your vehicle and choosing from their tailor-made results. Find offers as low as $29 a month.
Find the best rate for youHow to dispute a parking ticket
You can fight unfair parking tickets, but you need to follow the correct process. Here are some guidelines on the steps involved, which depend on the jurisdiction that issued the ticket.
Take photographs and gather evidence. If you believe you’ve been ticketed wrongfully, take time-stamped pictures (for example of nearby parking signs nearby). If there are witnesses willing to testify that you were legally parked, get their contact details.
Establish whether you have a case. The ticket should indicate what ordinance was violated. Consult the law to confirm whether you’ve broken the rules. If the ticket doesn’t indicate which ordinance was violated or state date or time of violation, that is a good reason to appeal. Even If you were in the wrong, you may be able to demonstrate extenuating circumstances that made it necessary for you to park the way you did.
Read the ticket for guidance on the appeals process. Your ticket should outline how to appeal and the deadline for doing so. This varies by jurisdiction. In New York City, parking disputes go through the Department of Finance; in Philadelphia, they go through the Philadelphia Parking Authority.
Submit your documentation with your appeal. What happens next will vary depending on jurisdiction, but this process may involve a review by a parking enforcement office, a hearing before a judge and the opportunity to appeal to a state court. With a good case and evidence on your side, your appeal might be granted after a review by an officer.
If not, you may have to go to court. If that’s the case, consider hiring an advocate to handle paperwork and help make a convincing case on your behalf. That’s where the photos and other evidence you gather, including witnesses, will be crucial. In the meantime, be careful not to pay the ticket because you are afraid you’ve missed the deadline.
It's worth the effort if you feel you've been wronged. By appealing, you can save money — and your reputation on the road.
People who shop around for auto refinance rates can save up to $5,198 on average.
With interest rates coming down, you can save substantially by refinancing your car loan at a lower rate. According to a report published by LendingTree, people who shop around for rates can save up to $5,198 on average. You can compare auto loan refinance rates offered by lenders near you through LendingTree. Click here to compare offers now.
